Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Scott Harrison's avatar

This reads as an apology for statism, nationalism and militarism.

The State of Israel and Hamas gangsters both extract resources from their population by force to fund their military, that is forcefully conscripted. They then use their militaries to attack and kill the other, destroying life and property indiscriminately.

Being horrified at that and opposed to it is not anti-Jewish or anti-Palestinian - it is Libertarian.

Expand full comment
Damon Hayhow's avatar

To other readers who find this rant as offensively anti-libertarian as I do, here is how Grok describes it:

"From a libertarian perspective, the rant is anti-libertarian because it prioritizes ethno-nationalism, state sovereignty, and wartime collectivism over individual liberty, non-aggression, and non-interventionism. Its criticism of government leaders and progressive activism might superficially align with libertarian skepticism, but these are subsumed by a nationalist, pro-state agenda that libertarians would reject. The rant’s tone and arguments are more aligned with right-wing nationalism or hardline Zionism than the principled individualism of libertarianism."

I wholeheartedly agree with this analysis and depiction. This article does NOT represent Libertarian ideology and I personally feel it has no place on Liberty Itch.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...