The concept of the welfare state was originally conceived as a safety net for the vulnerable, ensuring nobody falls below a dignified standard of living.
I appreciate the need for means testing; however, it is unreasonable to expect a group of taxpayers to make substantial contributions only to be denied benefits. In my own case, I have always been 'too rich' to receive unemployment benefits, and so I have always had to ensure that I have adequate funds at the ready. Hardly reasonable considering the taxes that I have paid.
I am expected to contribute, but have never been afforded even the most basic level of support when I have suffered one of life's reversals.
In many countries your argument would be correct. But Australia does not have a welfare contribution system. Our welfare is purely charity - no more, no less.
Just as you are not automatically entitled to receive charity from the Salvation Army or St Vincent de Paul, you are equally not entitled to charity from taxpayers.
However, we need to ensure that the desire to improve one's life is protected. The more we Pay (give) the less likely we need to bother to work and contribute to society.
Currently there is an ever increasing incentive to sit sit back on the couch, watch the sport on the TV and drink beer while we fly labour in from the Pacific Islands to pick the fruit. Really?? Someone needs a kick up the you know what and that someone sits and argues in Canberra. JMT.
I appreciate the need for means testing; however, it is unreasonable to expect a group of taxpayers to make substantial contributions only to be denied benefits. In my own case, I have always been 'too rich' to receive unemployment benefits, and so I have always had to ensure that I have adequate funds at the ready. Hardly reasonable considering the taxes that I have paid.
I am expected to contribute, but have never been afforded even the most basic level of support when I have suffered one of life's reversals.
In many countries your argument would be correct. But Australia does not have a welfare contribution system. Our welfare is purely charity - no more, no less.
Just as you are not automatically entitled to receive charity from the Salvation Army or St Vincent de Paul, you are equally not entitled to charity from taxpayers.
As always, a very well written contribution.
However, we need to ensure that the desire to improve one's life is protected. The more we Pay (give) the less likely we need to bother to work and contribute to society.
Currently there is an ever increasing incentive to sit sit back on the couch, watch the sport on the TV and drink beer while we fly labour in from the Pacific Islands to pick the fruit. Really?? Someone needs a kick up the you know what and that someone sits and argues in Canberra. JMT.