The American midterms have ignited a lively discussion on social media, and rightly so – every citizen has a vested interest in the future of their nation. The discussion ranges from extreme doomsday rhetoric to a more measured outlook for the future.
It got me thinking of when the Romans were dealing with their own dismal state of affairs in the late republic. And believe me – or rather, the sources – things now are nowhere near as grim as they could be.
It was 52 BC, and an event occurred that would contribute to the deepening political crisis leading up to civil war. For Cicero, it would mark a triumph equivalent to that of any grand entrance made by a returning general from war, referring to this watershed moment in a letter to his friend, Atticus, as the “Battle of Bovillae”.
Two rival politicians, accompanied by their “gang of roughs” as Cicero often referred to the armed entourages of characters that he was at odds with, clashed on the Via Appia, a main road leading into Rome.
Frustrated by continued obstruction and violence from the supporters of various candidates, Pompey was called upon to restore order to Rome.
Clodius and Milo
Publius Clodius Pulcher once dressed as a woman to enter the sacred space for women at the annual Bona Dea festival. Cicero testified against him at his trial dealing with sacrilege in 61 BC. Clodius was acquitted amidst allegations of bribery but, sadly for Cicero, he now had a new enemy.
Clodius embarked on an all-out assault to ruin Cicero. In 63 BC, as consul, Cicero secured legislation to have Roman citizens executed without a trial. Subsequently, he ordered the execution of the conspirators involved in Catiline’s plan to overthrow the sitting consuls. In 58 BC, Clodius had him exiled, and in an added blow, seized Cicero’s house on the Palatine and had it burned down.
Roman politics had descended into such depths of depravity and despair during this fateful period that Cicero, reflecting on earlier troubles in his speech, Pro Sestio, wrote:
‘You recollect, O judges, that on that day the Tiber was filled with the corpses of the citizens, that the sewers were choked up; that blood was wiped up out of the forum with sponges; so that all men thought that such a vast number and such a magnificent show of gladiators could not have been provided by any private individual, or plebeian, but must be the exhibition of some patrician and man of praetorian rank.’
Titus Annius Milo, an ally of the optimates and bitter enemy of Clodius, was instrumental in the senate’s vote to secure Cicero’s return from exile in 57 BC. As a result of this, Cicero devoted himself to helping Milo secure a consulship for 52 BC. Little did he know that he would soon be defending his friend against a charge of murder.
On the Road to Perdition
In January of 52 BC, Clodius and Milo crossed paths on the Via Appia. According to Asconius, writing in first century AD, a fight broke out between their followers rather than directly between the two men themselves. That happened following the outbreak, and resulted in the death of Clodius. According to Asconius, his body was left on the side of the road where it was found, taken back to his wife, and the following day was carried to the senate house and his body cremated there. This also resulted in the burning down of the Curia and the attached Basilica Porcia.
Due to the ongoing chaos where the appointment of consuls had been frustrated by continued obstruction and violence from the supporters of various candidates, Pompey was called upon to restore order to Rome. He was appointed sole consul under decree – the senatus consultum ultimum (SCU). Some had called for him to be appointed dictator, but he refused. The SCU was the lever used in the name of protecting Rome from harm.
For Cicero, it would mark a triumph equivalent to that of any grand entrance made by a returning general from war
Milo was ultimately tried and convicted of the murder of Clodius, but he went into exile and died in 48 BC.
Our Eleventh-Hour Reprieve
There is so much than can be drawn upon from the ancient world to show the contrast with where we are today. It is a matter of degrees in relation to open physical brutality as described above, but as a parallel to the existing undercurrent of tensions, there is little difference. We confront the same toxic vices exhibited by our political class as they did over two thousand years ago.
Right now there is a wall between our eras which separates us from the worst of all atrocities. But it remains valid to highlight the fractious nature of political warfare and the effects it ultimately has upon citizens, who merely seek to live their lives in peace and with good intentions.




